Store  |  Projects  |  Tools  |  Techniques  |  Videos  |  Subscribe  |  Renew  |  Customer Service   

Woodworking Magazine Blog

Posted 2/1/2010 in All Weblog Posts | Raw Materials
Bookmark and Share

In college I had a girlfriend who was half Japanese, half German and entirely unpredictable. And for a kid raised in Arkansas, she was quite the exotic Axis-power antidote to my small-town upbringing.

My grandmother flipped her wig when I brought the girlfriend to the Natural State for a visit (mission accomplished). I was exposed to food and culture that opened my eyes to the larger world. Her dad was a Zen Buddhism professor, their home was filled with Asian ink paintings and they ate all manner of foods that were new to me: sashimi, Ethiopian, Northern Indian, Middle Eastern, and stuffed Chicago pizza.

But all this education came at a price. The relationship was tumultuous. She was still in love with her high-school boyfriend, a poet. (Handy hint: In the writing world, "poet" always trumps "newspaper hack.") She needed to talk about "feelings," which is difficult for a male who has only one of those things.

In the end, she dumped me for some guy she met in Japan one summer.

And this explains why I prefer quartersawn wood.

On Friday, I spent the last couple hours of my week prepping some walnut for the reproduction of a White Water Shaker table I'm building for the June 2010 issue. The original's base was built using quartersawn walnut, so I spent a couple weeks trying to hunt some down.

As I was marking out the tenons on the apron pieces, Publisher Steve Shanesy came into the shop to ask a couple questions and looked over the stock stacked on my bench.

"Quartersawn?" he asked. "Really? What a waste. I guess flatsawn walnut was just too racy for the these Shakers."

I made a joke that quartersawn walnut could have been the MDF of the 19th century – predictable but boring.

It's true that quartersawn stock won't show off walnut's beguiling cathedrals. But I can tell you that the wood has other joys, which are more subtle. It is a joy to work by hand. Dead stable. Planes and saws beautifully. And it doesn't cup. When I inspected and measured the original table, the fact that the maker chose quartersawn walnut became a critical point.

The joinery on the table's base is proper, neat and seamless. So it would follow that the selection of the wood would also be as deliberate. And this seemed a message that was sent to me from across the last 150 years ago by the maker.

And I also know something that Steve doesn't. This walnut hasn't had the bejeesus steamed out of it like other commercial walnut we get. So when I put a little oil and shellac on it I know that it's going to have a gorgeous warm tone. It won't scream "look at me," but then, I really don't like screaming.

Speaking of which, after getting dumped by the Dragon lady, I swore off women for a while, and stumbled into a relationship with Lucy, whom I would later marry. She is – and I know I'm going to catch hell for this at home – a lot like the quartersawn oak, walnut and maple I enjoy building with. She's from Kentucky. Stable (even more so than I am). And she has been a joy to work with these last 20 years, building our careers and a family.

And, of course, I know something about her that you don't. But that's a topic for another kind of blog.

— Christopher Schwarz


Monday, February 01, 2010 1:50:08 PM UTC
Comparing your wife to Oak Chris ? Have the years taught you nothing.. I'll continue to follow your progress in the emergency ward with great sympathy and much interest.
Sean C.
Monday, February 01, 2010 2:44:52 PM UTC
Ha! Especially after describing said quartersawn wood as "predictable but boring"... we'll be seeing an article on building doghouses in an upcoming issue, I presume?
D Grant
Monday, February 01, 2010 3:23:58 PM UTC
or perhaps an nicely upholstered couch???

Gene
Monday, February 01, 2010 3:34:48 PM UTC
Well, I think a comparison to quartersawn can be a good thing, especially when talking about someone you want to spend your life with. Sure, have fun with flatsawn, quilted or birdseye. Tiger is amazing. They're all gorgeous but somewhere, someone's dealing with their twists and tearout.
Monday, February 01, 2010 3:36:59 PM UTC
Chris:

Ignore the naysayers; I think my beloved would be pleased to be compared to quartersawn domestic hardwoods! Stable, reliable over the long term, evincing a warm tone when appropriately treated, and responsive to loving treatment and handling. What's not to like in that description!

It also may be that my wife is a craftsperson of remarkable skill, who understands the relationship between the maker and materials.

Enjoy building the bench--finding quartersawn walnut here is a needle-haystack scenario
Ed Furlong
Monday, February 01, 2010 4:48:17 PM UTC
I'm with Sean. I think you're boned. :)
Chuck Brewer
Monday, February 01, 2010 5:05:02 PM UTC
I thought it was a compliment as well, and wondered what you had done wrong that you were buttering her up from.

And remember: women are like walnut - they are better if you don't get them steamed.
John Cashman
Monday, February 01, 2010 5:29:50 PM UTC
Your writing astounds me...poet...I think so...in words and wood...
David Nordrum
Monday, February 01, 2010 5:43:10 PM UTC
Actually, Chris, visions of Greene & Greene park benches slide-show through my head, with arms customized to serve as headrests. With a nice Stickley Tabouret to hold the stack of blankets repurposed from newsprint. Besides, poets and newspaper hacks (like, say, Mark Twain (?) and Hemingway) write from the same well - lifetimes of experieces. Even Faulkner and Grisham, as well as Poe and Dickinson. Just might be an article ... complete with that jump from feelings to quartersawn wood. That one really grabbed me.

Meanwhile, I'm left to contemplate whether my better half, from the Philippines, would appreciate likening her to a fine piece of quartersawn narra. On the other hand, if you have to think twice about what you will say, would it be the better part of valor not to aay it?
Bruce Jackson
Monday, February 01, 2010 6:12:55 PM UTC
Hey Chris, a couple of router mats and some plane shavings on top the workbench and you'll get a fine night's rest.
Claro walnut (aka western walnut, etc.) often has an attractive, interesting quartersawn surface, especially if there is a nice marbled color variation.
Rob
Monday, February 01, 2010 8:28:56 PM UTC
Comparing your wife to a piece of wood that is "predictable and boring!" It's been nice knowing you. Go with god, my son.

David

PS. Would you mind leaving me that Wayne Anderson plane?
David B.
Monday, February 01, 2010 10:33:37 PM UTC
Yes, Chris, vaya con Dios. Please put me in your list of bequests for the Nicholson bench. Thank you ... perhaps we will meet as neighbors on matching Greene & Greene park benches.
Bruce Jackson
Monday, February 01, 2010 11:40:20 PM UTC
Quarter sawn doesn't always mean plain. In curly maple the most tortured curl is where the grain is quarter sawn. I've been wanting to get a sawyer to set aside a nice figured log and have it quarter sawn. So far the one guy I approached about it looked at me like I was nuts.

Tuesday, February 02, 2010 12:37:17 AM UTC
I'm with George on this one. Depending on the wood, quartersawn is the way to go.
Hey George, when you find someone to saw one of those logs up for you, be sure to pass their info along. I'd love to get my hands on some quartersawn curly maple.
David Chidester
Tuesday, February 02, 2010 2:19:19 AM UTC
WAS (Wives Against Schwarz)just gained another member!

Brad
Brad McDonald
Tuesday, February 02, 2010 2:54:35 AM UTC
Getting in trouble for comparing wife to quartersawn oak:

Just tell her she has a nice figure.


--GG

Gye Greene
Tuesday, February 02, 2010 4:55:46 PM UTC
So let me get this straight.... You are comparing The LOYL to a stick of timber. And then say it get better looking with a bit of oil, and doesn't scream.
I almost feel as bad for Lucy as I do my own LOML.
Haha. Thanks for another great episode.
Jesse Khangura
Comments are closed.

Need More Posts? Search This Blog

Loading

Google Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
 Copyright 2010; FW Media Inc. All rights reserved.